Carbon credit leakage: emissions beyond the project boundary
Questions for understanding whether a project shifts emissions beyond its boundary and how that risk is treated in quantification.
At a glance
Leakage is an increase in emissions outside the project boundary caused by the project activity. Ask which activities or markets could be affected, which evidence is used and how the effect is treated in verified outcomes. It differs from reversal and has no universal deduction percentage.

Author: Carbonetica Registry. Prepared on
In carbon credit projects, leakage is an increase in emissions outside the project boundary caused by the project activity. Assessing it means understanding what might move, where, which evidence supports that assessment and how the effect is treated in the outcome calculation. A line on a map does not rule out effects beyond it.
The Madonie photograph comes from Carbonetica’s archive and provides landscape context. It does not suggest that leakage has been identified in the projects depicted.
Activity displacement and market effects
Verra’s leakage FAQs distinguish two mechanisms in land-use projects. An activity may physically move outside the area, or a change in supply may alter market incentives and encourage production and emissions elsewhere.
As an explanatory scenario, protecting land without considering where a previous activity will continue may leave part of the problem outside the monitored area. This is not a client case, and it does not establish that every conservation project faces the same risk. The activity needs to be assessed using its own evidence and applicable method.
Market effects can extend beyond neighbouring land. A photograph or a measurement limited to the project site therefore cannot establish that leakage is absent. The VCS rules cited describe that programme; they are not automatically Carbonetica requirements.
Distinguish leakage, additionality and reversal
- Additionality
- Asks whether the outcome goes beyond what would have happened under the reference scenario. Our guide to additionality evidence covers that test.
- Leakage
- Asks whether the intervention causes emissions outside its boundary and how they are included in quantification.
- Reversal
- Concerns the subsequent loss of carbon already stored. Duration, responsibility and remedies are covered in our permanence and buffer guide.
A buffer intended to address reversal risk does not, by itself, demonstrate that leakage has been assessed. These are different questions. Check the relevant rules rather than treating a reserve contribution as a universal answer.
Evidence to request from the proponent
- Possible mechanism. Which activities, operators or products might be affected by displacement? The explanation needs to address the actual project activity.
- Assessment boundary. Which areas or markets are considered, and why? Ask which effects are excluded and what methodological justification supports that decision.
- Data and period. Where does the information come from, how recent is it and which observations are updated through monitoring? If a model is used, request the relevant assumptions.
- Mitigation measures. Which actions seek to prevent displacement, and how is implementation checked? An intention to prevent an effect is not evidence that it is zero.
- Quantity treatment. Where does leakage appear in the calculation, and which document verifies its treatment? A zero deduction needs a basis consistent with the methodology, rather than a verbal assurance.
Keep a record of the question, answer, supporting reference and unresolved issue. If commercial data is confidential, ask which evidence or verifier conclusions are accessible and what limitations remain for your assessment.
Reading deductions and uncertainty
There is no percentage to apply indiscriminately to every carbon credit. Identify the methodology and version, check how it treats the relevant risk and follow the calculation to the net outcome. An explicit deduction makes the treatment visible; its size alone does not measure overall project quality.
Ask whether the figure is already included in the final total and how overlap with other adjustments is avoided. To connect calculations with units, see our guide to carbon credit monitoring reports. Do not infer a quantity available for sale from a gross project outcome alone.
Before deciding on a project
The existence of a risk does not automatically settle the assessment. What matters is how it is identified, mitigated, quantified and verified. If a key connection between assumptions and results is missing, request further evidence before using the units in a public statement.
Carbonetica’s public project pages provide a starting point for identifying a project. Request clarification with the project, methodology and leakage document reference. Registration does not replace independent verification or automatically certify the absence of effects outside the boundary or the buyer’s climate neutrality.